2017-2018: "A Season of Crossroads": The Complete Works of Shakespeare (Abridged), No Problem/The Terezin Promise, Bye Bye Birdie
2016-2017: "A Season of 'I'm Not Dead Yet!'": Is He Dead?; Blithe Spirit; Wit; Jesus Christ Superstar
2015-2016: "A Season of Fairytales": The Hobbit; Fit; Atypical Boy; Cinderella (Revival)
2014-2015: Godspell (Revival); Lockdown; Bang Bang, You're Dead; God's Favorite
2013-2014: Thoroughly Modern Millie; A Streetcar Named Desire
2012-2013: The Curious Savage; The Diary of Anne Frank
2011-2012: Fiddler on the Roof; Arsenic and Old Lace
2010-2011: The Man Who Came to Dinner; Rumors
2009-2010: The Crucible; Guys and Dolls
2008-2009: George Washington Slept Here; Twelve Angry Jurors
2007-2008: The Miracle Worker; Grease
2006-2007: The Uninvited; Rumors
2005-2006: The Trouble with Summer People; Steel Magnolias; The Pirates of Penzance
2004-2005: I Remember Mama; Odd Couple
2003-2004: You Can't Take it With You; South Pacific
2002-2003: Cheaper by the Dozen; The Diary of Anne Frank
2001-2002: Winnie the Pooh; George Washington Slept Here; Annie Get Your Gun
2000-2001: The Man Who Came to Dinner; The Mousetrap
1999-2000: Rumors; My Fair Lady
1998-1999: The Curious Savage; The Miracle Worker
1997-1998: You Can't Take it With You; Guys and Dolls
1996-1997: Wait Until Dark; I Remember Mama
1995-1996: Arsenic and Old Lace; Oklahoma!
1994-1995: The Good Doctor; Barefoot in the Park
1993-1994: Ten Little Indians; The Sound of Music
1992-1993: Rumors; Plaza Suite
1991-1992: The Miracle Worker; The Pirates of Penzance
1990-1991: Blithe Spirit; The Diary of Anne Frank
1989-1990: Harvey; The King and I
1988-1989: Arsenic and Old Lace
1987-1988: Charley's Aunt; My Fair Lady
1986-1987: The Odd Couple
1985-1986: The Man Who Came to Dinner; Guys and Dolls
1984-1985: Barefoot in the Park; Turn of the Screw
1983-1984: Up the Down Staircase; Fiddler on the Roof
1982-1983: The Steadfast Tin Soldier; Dracula; Sorry Wrong Number; Lily Daw and the Three Ladies; Insanity of Mary Girard; The Lottery; Bessie, the Bandit's Beautiful Baby; The Fantasticks
1981-1982: Ten Little Indians; The Good Doctor
1980-1981: You Can't Take it With You; God's Favorite
1979-1980: Hello, Dolly!; Five for Bad Luck; The Day After Forever; The Dear Departed; Silver Whistle
1978-1979: MASH; The Sisters McIntosh; The Bald Soprano; Who Am I This Time?; Mousetrap
1977-1978: Oklahoma!; The Diary of Anne Frank
1976-1977: Life With Father
1975-1976: The Man Who Came to Dinner; Where Have All the Lightning Bugs Gone; Louder I Can't Hear You; Scenes from the American Way
1974-1975: You Can't Take it With You; The Impossible Years
1973-1974: Night of One Acts
1972-1973: Life With Father
1971-1972: Li'l Abner
1970-1971: Winnie the Pooh; Alas, Babylon
1969-1970: Annie
1968-1969: Arsenic and Old Lace
1966-1967: Bye, Bye Birdie
1961-1962: The Man Who Came to Dinner
1956-1957: Sparks, An In-between
1955-1956: Three on a Bench; I Love You Truly
1952-1953: Grandma Pulls the Strings; Collector's Item; Young As You Look
1951-1952: Mister Vincent; Double Date
1950-1951: The Great Allowance Battle; Opened By Mistake
1949-1950: The Perfect Gentleman; The Day After Forever
1948-1949: Sparks
1947-1948: The Pot Boiler
1946-1947: Mansions; Grandma Pulls the Strings; Sham
1945-1946: Yes Means No; Teen Magic
1942-1943: Sky Road
1941-1942: Murder at Rehearsal
1940-1941: New Fires
1939-1940: Spring Fever
1938-1939: Shirt Sleeves
1937-1938: Rose of Plymouth Town
1936-1937: The Goose Hangs High; The Lord's Prayer
1935-1936: Not So Long Ago; Farewell Cruel World
1934-1935: Pink and Patches;The Minuet; Out of the Darkness
1933-1934: The Woman Who Understood Men; Skidding
1932-1933: The Pot Boiler; To The Ladies
1931-1932: Napoleon's Barber; Skidding
1930-1931: Daddy- Long-Legs
1929-1930: Buddies; The Patsy